PERFORMANCE STUDY OF A SULFUR RECOVERY PLANT FROM FLARE GAS USING ASPEN HYSYS SULSIM SIMULATION
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.65405/2f2nze27Keywords:
Alumina catalyst; Challenging feed; Sulfur recovery unit; SulsimAbstract
Sulfur recovery is an essential process in the midstream and refining stages of the oil and gas industry. Changes in feed composition, temperature, and pressure; deterioration of equipment and catalysts; and suboptimal operation caused by inadequate control of temperature, pressure, and air flow rate are among the challenges that reduce the performance of sulfur recovery units. Poor performance can lead to safety and environmental problems. This study aims to improve the performance of a sulfur recovery unit at a gas plant. A modified three-stage Claus process model, using Aspen HYSYS V14 Sulsim, was used to simulate the behavior of an actual sulfur recovery unit and establish the base case. The base-case performance was 92.90%. Adding a selective oxidation converter increased performance to 98.46%. Adding a tail-gas section with a recycle stream further increased performance to 99.96%. The simulation procedure developed in this study can help process engineers operate sulfur recovery units effectively under challenging conditions.
Downloads
References
1. Moore CW, Zielinska B, Petron G, Jackson RB. Air impacts of increased natural gas acquisition, processing, and use: a critical review, Environmental science & technology, 2014; 48(15): 8349-8359.
2. Aaron D, Tsouris C. Separation of CO2 from flue gas: a review, Separation Science and Technolo-gy, 2005; 40(3): 321-348.
3. Paskall HG. Capability of the modified-Claus process; Western Research and Development, 1979.
4. Bohme G, Sames J. The seven deadly sins of sulfur recovery. In Sulfur Conference, Calgary, Alberta, Canada,1999.
5. Hyne JB. Recent developments in sulfur production from hydrogen sulfide-containing gases. ACS syposium series, 1982,183:37-56.
6. Beavon D, Kouzel B, Ward J. Claus processing of novel acid gas streams. In ACS symposium series, 1982; 183: 57-68. 1155 16th ST, NW, Washington, DC 20036 USA: ACS.
7. Selim H, Gupta AK, Al Shoaibi A. Effect of reaction parameters on the quality of captured sulfur in Claus process, Applied energy, 2013, 104: 772-776.
8. Elsner MP, Menge M, Müller C, Agar DW. The Claus process: teaching an old dog new tricks, Ca-talysisToday, 2003; 79: 487-494.
9. van Nisselrooy PFMT, Lagas JA. Super Claus reduces SO2, emission by the use of a new selective oxidation catalyst, Catalysis today, 2003; 16(2): 263-271.
10. Nedez C, Ray JL. A new Claus catalyst to reduce atmospheric pollution, Catalysis today, 1996; 27(1-2):49-53.
11. Pearson MJ. Alumina catalysts in low-temperature Claus process, Industrial & Engineering Chem-istry Product Research and Development, 1997; 16(2): 154-158.
12. Tong S, Dalla Lana IG, Chuang KT. Effect of catalyst shape on the hydrolysis of COS and CS2 in a simulated Claus converter. Industrial & engineering chemistry research, 1997; 36(10): 4087-4093.
13. Baglio JA, Susa TJ, Wortham DW, Trickett EA, Lewis TJ. Lanthanum oxide-based catalysts for the Claus process, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Product Research and Development, 1982; 21(3):408-415.
14. Monnery W.D, Hawboldt K.A, Pollock A.E, Svrcek W.Y. Ammonia pyrolysis and oxidation in the Claus furnace, Industrial & engineering chemistry research, 2001; 40(1): 44-151.
15. Sinha S, Raj A, Al-Shoaibi AS, Alhassan SM, Chung SH. Benzene destruction in Claus process by sulfur dioxide: a reaction kinetics study, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 2014; 53(26):10608-10617.
16. Keller AE, Ramani S, Allison JD, Lusk SE, Hatcher NA, Swinney LD, Shaver RS. ConocoPhillips Co. 2009. Increased capacity sulfur recovery plant and process for recovering elemental sulfur. U.S. Patent 7,501,111.
17. El-Bishtawi R, Haimour NM. Claus recycle with double combustion process. Fuel Processing Tech-nology, 2004; 86(3):245-260.
18. Karan K, Behie LA. CS2 formation in the Claus reaction furnace: a kinetic study of methane - sulfur and methane - hydrogen sulfide reactions, Industrial & engineering chemistry research, 2004; 43(13):3304-3313.
19. Raj A, Sinha S. Reaction mechanism for the oxidation of aromatic contaminants present in feed gas to Claus process, Energy Procedia, 2015; 66: 61-64.
20. Ibrahim S, Al Shoaibi A, Gupta AK. Toluene destruction in thermal stage of Claus reactor with oxygen enriched air, Applied Energy, 2014; 115: 1-8.
21. Ibrahim S, Rahman RK, Raj A. Effects of H2O in the Feed of Sulfur Recovery Unit on Sulfur Production and Aromatics Emission from Claus Furnace, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Re-search, 2017; 56(41): 11713-11725.
22. Mahdipoor HR, Ashkezari AD. Feasibility study of a sulfur recovery unit containing mercaptans in lean acid gas feed, Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2016; 31: 585-588.
23. Asil AG, Shahsavand A, Mirzaei S. Maximization of sulfur recovery efficiency via coupled modifi-cation of GTU and SRU processes, Egyptian Journal of Petroleum, 2017; 26(3): 579-592.
24. Chidambaram S. Thermal Damage of Sulfur Processed Chamber under Claus Operating Reaction Conditions-A Case Study, Case Studies in Construction Materials, 2018; 8: 517-529.
25. Ibrahim S, Raj A. Kinetic simulation of acid gas (H2S and CO2) destruction for simultaneous syngas and sulfur recovery, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 2016; 55(24): 6743-6752.
26. Sassi M, Gupta AK. Sulfur recovery from acid gas using the Claus process and high temperature air combustion (HiTAC) technology, American Journal of Environmental Sciences, 2008; 4(5):502.
27. Beavon DK, Fleck RN. Beavon. Sulfur Removal Process for Claus Plant Tail Gas, Advances in chemistry. 1975.
28. Swaim CD. The Shell Claus Offgas Treating (SCOT) Process, Advances in Chemistry, 1975.
29. Sung CY, Al Hashimi S, McCormick A, Tsapatsis M, Cococcioni M. Density functional theory study on the adsorption of H2S and other Claus process tail gas components on copper-and silver-exchanged Y zeolites, The Journal of Physical Chemistry C, 2012; 116(5): 3561-3575.
30. Al Wahedi Y, Torres AI, Al Hashimi S, Dowling NI, Daoutidis P, Tsapatsis M. Economic assessment of temperature swing adsorption systems as Claus tail gas clean up units, Chemical Engineering Science, 2015; 126:186-195.
31. Buchanan JS, Stern DL, Nariman KE, Teitman GJ, Sodomin JF, Johnson DL. Regenerable solid sorbents for Claus tail gas cleanup: A treatment process for the catalytic removal of SO2 and H2S, Industrial & engineering chemistry research, 1996; 35(8): 2495-2499.
32. Khudenko BM, Gitman GM, Wechsler TE. Oxygen based Claus process for recovery of sulfur from H2S gases, Journal of environmental engineering, 1993; 119(6): 1233-1251.
33. Nabikandi NJ, Fatemi S. Kinetic modelling of a commercial sulfur recovery unit based on Claus straight through process: Comparison with equilibrium model, Journal of Industrial and Engi-neering Chemistry, 2015; 30:50-63.
34. Jones D, Bhattacharyya D, Turton R, Zitney SE. Rigorous kinetic modeling and optimization study of a modified Claus unit for an integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) power plant with CO2 capture, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 2012; 51(5): 2362-2375.
35. Rahman RK, Raj A, Ibrahim S, Khan MI, Al Muhairi NO. Reduction in natural gas consumption in sulfur recovery units through kinetic simulation using a detailed reaction mechanism, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 2018; 57(5): 1417-1428.
36. Mohammed S, Raj A, Al Shoaibi A. Effects of fuel gas addition to Claus furnace on the formation of soot precursors, Combustion and Flame, 2016; 168: 240-254.
37. Ghahraloud H, Farsi M, Rahimpour MR. Modeling and optimization of an industrial Claus process: Thermal and catalytic section, Journal of the Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers, 2017; 76: 1-9.
38. Manenti F, Papasidero D, Bozzano G, Ranzi E. Model-based optimization of sulfur recovery units, Computers & Chemical Engineering, 2014; 66:244-251.
39. Kazempour H, Pourfayaz F, Mehrpooya M. Modeling and multi-optimization of thermal section of Claus process based on kinetic model, Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 2017; 38: 235-244.
40. Zughbi HD, Razzak SA. Simulation of flow and chemical reactions in a Claus sulfur converter, In-dustrial & engineering chemistry research, 2005; 44(26): 9828-9839.
41. Sinha S, Raj A, AlShoaibi AS, Alhassan SM, Chung, SH. Toluene destruction in the Claus process by sulfur dioxide: a reaction kinetics study, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 2014; 53(42):16293-16308.
42. Sinha S, Raj A, Al Shoaibi AS, Chung SH. Reaction mechanism for m-xylene oxidation in the Claus process by sulfur dioxide, The Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 2015; 119(38): 9889-9900.












